This title of this post will seem odd to Catholics, and improbable to fundamentalist and some evangelical Christians. I ask forbearance. Since I regularly use the term “Catholic Christian” in posts to Christianity Richly, it deserves explanation.
The two words are redundant for anyone who has entered the Church. To say Catholic is to say Christian—and to say it with intensity, a sense of history, deep reverence, and spiritual vitality. “Catholic” is not an adjective. Catholic is a noun meaning “Christian of the all-embracing (Greek katholikos, ‘universal’) Church, the Body of Christ.”
Yet some still outside the Church view the term “Catholic Christian” as an oxymoron—contradictory terms used in connection with each other. I encountered this not long ago, talking with a homeless man. After we chatted for a bit, he said, “You’ve been so kind. You must have a good church.” I replied that I did, St. Mary’s Catholic Church. He quickly countered, “Oh, well. That may be OK for you, but I prefer the Christian religion.”
Some will smile at this anecdote. Others will find nothing ironic at all, but rather that the man’s statement mirrors their impression of the Catholic Church. If you are in the latter group (and I was at one time in my life), please be patient. You’ve found your way to this post. Read others. See what the Holy Spirit and your own sense of fairness say to you.
If you are a Catholic, I apologize for using two words where one should do.